The Bay Log · Stories of San Diego Bay

The Man Who Bought Downtown for Twenty-Seven Cents an Acre

In 1867 a furniture dealer from San Francisco went to a public auction in San Diego and bid on a stretch of open land along the bay. When the bidding closed, Alonzo Horton owned about 800 acres of it. Accounts differ on the exact acreage, but they agree on the price: $265 for the lot, usually given as roughly 27 cents an acre. That ground is now downtown San Diego.

A Town Set Back from Its Harbor

The San Diego that Horton found in 1867 sat inland, in the district now called Old Town. It had a plaza, adobe houses, and a long Spanish and Mexican past behind it. It was a few miles from the deep water where ships could come in and tie up.

Horton was convinced the town belonged on the bay. A port city, in his view, should stand at the edge of its port, where cargo and passengers came ashore. The land he bought ran along that edge, and he meant to build the city there.

It looked like a bad bet in 1867. Horton was buying empty ground and wagering that people would leave an established town to settle on it. The auction price shows how little the land was thought to be worth.

Small Blocks, Many Corners

Horton named his tract New Town and laid it out on paper before there was much on the ground to show. He drew the blocks small. Small blocks meant more streets, and more streets meant more corners.

That choice was deliberate. A corner lot faces two streets, so it has more frontage and more foot traffic, and it is the lot a merchant wants for a store. By cutting the land into short blocks, Horton multiplied the number of corner lots he had to offer. Walk downtown today and the blocks are still short, a grid you can cross in a few minutes on foot.

Giving Land Away to Sell Land

Horton also gave land to anyone who would build on it. The logic was a developer's logic. An empty plat sells slowly. A plat with houses, shops and churches already standing on it sells itself, because each new building makes the lots around it worth more. Every structure someone else put up on a free lot raised the value of the lots Horton still held.

The Wharf and the Hotel

A town on the bay needed a way to reach the ships, so in 1869 Horton built a wharf at the foot of Fifth Avenue. Vessels could now land goods and passengers at New Town itself rather than somewhere else on the shore. The wharf tied his grid of small blocks directly to the water, which was the whole point of putting the town there.

In 1870 he opened the Horton House, a hotel in the heart of New Town. A hotel tells arriving visitors that a place intends to last. It gave travelers coming off the boats somewhere to stay in the new district, and it gave New Town a building people could point to.

Old Town Loses the Argument

The plan worked faster than anyone watching the 1867 auction would have guessed. Within a few years New Town had overtaken Old Town as the center of San Diego. Business followed the wharf, and settlers followed the business.

Then, in 1872, fire struck Old Town. Whatever chance the old settlement had of holding its place ended there. The center of San Diego had moved to the bayfront, onto the land Horton had bought for $265.

What Carries His Name

Horton lived to see his New Town become the downtown of a real city. He died in 1909. His name stayed on the map at Horton Plaza, in the middle of the district he laid out.

The arithmetic of his purchase is the part people remember: 27 cents an acre for what became the most valuable ground in San Diego. The decisions that made the land valuable came after the auction. He drew short blocks and many corners, he gave land to people who would build, and he put a wharf on the water and a hotel behind it.

The bayfront he bet on is easiest to read from the water. Sail in past Point Loma and Ballast Point, along Shelter Island and Harbor Island, and the downtown skyline rises ahead on the shore Horton chose. JADA, a 65-foot wooden yacht launched in 1938, keeps her home port at Harbor Island, a short sail from that skyline. Our San Diego Bay history sail shows you the city from the side Horton built it to face.

Sources: San Diego History Center; The Journal of San Diego History; Wikipedia articles "Alonzo Horton," "Horton Plaza," and "Old Town, San Diego."

Hear this story where it happened. JADA sails past this very spot. Join the San Diego Bay History Sail →

← All Bay Log stories