For 132 years the America's Cup sat in the New York Yacht Club. Every challenger since 1851 had sailed home without it. In 1983 the run ended. Dennis Conner, a San Diego Yacht Club sailor helming for New York, lost the Cup to Australia II off Newport, Rhode Island. He became the first American skipper ever to lose the oldest trophy in international sport.
Four years later he won it back. In early 1987, off Fremantle in Western Australia, Conner sailed Stars & Stripes 87 to victory and brought the Cup home. He did not bring it back to New York. He brought it to his own club, the San Diego Yacht Club on Point Loma. For the next eight years every race for the Cup was sailed in the open Pacific off the point, and San Diego defended it three times.
The first defense did not follow the usual pattern. Normally a holder sets a date and challengers spend years fighting each other in elimination trials for the right to race. In 1987 a New Zealand syndicate led by Michael Fay read the Cup's founding document, the Deed of Gift, and served a challenge straight under its terms. The deed allowed very large yachts, and Fay's team built one: a giant monohull, far bigger than anything the Cup had seen in decades.
San Diego answered with a catamaran. The deed said nothing to forbid one, and a light, fast twin-hulled boat could outrun the big monohull easily. Conner sailed the catamaran Stars & Stripes off Point Loma in September 1988 and won both races by wide margins.
The real contest then moved to a courtroom. The Cup is held in trust under the Deed of Gift, and disputes over it go to the New York courts. New Zealand argued that a catamaran against a monohull was no fair match. A trial judge first agreed and awarded the Cup to New Zealand. The San Diego Yacht Club appealed, and in 1990 the higher courts restored the result on the water. The 1988 match was decided about two years after it was sailed.
The fight over 1988 pushed the Cup toward a new set of rules. For 1992 the boats were built to the new International America's Cup Class: long, narrow monohulls with tall rigs, designed for close racing. The trials were open again, and challengers came from around the world to sail in San Diego.
This time Conner did not defend. In the American selection trials he lost to Bill Koch, an industrialist who had never sailed in an America's Cup before and who poured his fortune and an engineering team into a syndicate called America3. Koch's yacht won the defender's berth.
The challenger was Il Moro di Venezia, the Italian entry backed by Raul Gardini and skippered by Paul Cayard. The match was sailed off Point Loma in May 1992. America3 won it four races to one, and the Cup stayed at the San Diego Yacht Club.
The third defense ended the San Diego era. Team New Zealand came in 1995 with a syndicate led by Peter Blake and a skipper named Russell Coutts. Their boat was Black Magic, and through the challenger trials it was rarely beaten.
Conner won the American trials and raced the match in Young America. It was a mismatch from the start. Black Magic won the first race, and the second, and every race after. The final score was 5-0. It was one of the most lopsided results in the Cup's history, and it was the second time an American defender had lost the trophy, both times with Conner at the helm.
The Cup left San Diego for Auckland. It had spent about eight years in the city, and it has not returned.
For eight years the Cup brought syndicates, designers and crews to the city. The defense was run from a compound on the waterfront, and sailors set out from the bay to race on courses off Point Loma, in open ocean where the wind and the swell could test the boats properly. Spectators watched from boats of every size. On race days the harbor emptied toward the point.
The races themselves left almost no mark on the landscape. The courses were out in the open sea, and the water there looks now as it looked then. What remains is the route. A boat leaving San Diego Bay for those courses passed the bait barge and the Zuniga jetty and turned out past Point Loma, with the lighthouse and Cabrillo National Monument on the ridge above. A sailor heading out of the harbor today follows the same line.
JADA knows long-distance racing from her own past: she raced to Hawaii five times. From her decks the Point Loma horizon looks much as it did when the Cup boats crossed it. That passage out of the harbor, and the history of the waters around it, is part of the San Diego Bay history sail.
Sources: San Diego Yacht Club history; America's Cup official history; Wikipedia articles "America's Cup," "1987 America's Cup," "1988 America's Cup," "1992 America's Cup," "1995 America's Cup," "Dennis Conner," "Bill Koch" and "Team New Zealand."
Hear this story where it happened. JADA sails past this very spot. Join the San Diego Bay History Sail →