On the old charts of San Diego Bay, the water off the Point Loma shore marks a hazard where a yacht basin now lies. It was a sandbank called Shelter Island shoal, shallow enough for a boat to find it with her keel. Today a road runs along the top of it, with marinas, restaurants and hotels on both sides. Every grain of sand under them came up from the bottom of the bay.
A few miles east, in front of the airport, a second strip of land sits in the water where there was once only bay. Harbor Island is younger and straighter than Shelter Island, and it was made the same way. Both are peninsulas, joined to the mainland. Both are called islands anyway, and both were built from what the dredges brought up.
San Diego Bay is broad and well protected, which is why ships have wanted it since the first Europeans sailed in. Much of it is shallow, though, and the deep water a large ship needs runs in a narrow channel. Every generation that brought bigger ships into the bay had to dig deeper for them.
Digging a harbor produces spoil: the sand, silt and shell a dredge pumps or scoops off the bottom. A dredge can move huge amounts of it, and all of it has to go somewhere. Dumping it at sea costs time and fuel. Putting it on a shoal inside the bay costs far less, and it leaves something behind that can be used.
The shoal off Point Loma was the obvious place. Work on building it up began in 1934. Spoil went onto the bank over the years that followed, and the great push came after World War II, when the bay was deepened again and the dredges had sand to spare. The bank rose above the tide and kept rising. By 1950 the island was mostly complete, and a causeway tied it to the Point Loma shore. The causeway is the reason the name has never been strictly accurate. You can drive to Shelter Island without crossing any water.
Nobody had ever lived on it, owned a house on it or farmed it, so the land came with no history at all. The 1950s supplied one. Marinas went in along the sheltered inner shore, facing the yacht basin between the island and Point Loma. Restaurants and hotels followed. The Bali Hai opened in 1955, and Polynesian-style hotels gave the new land a South Seas look that was much in fashion in that decade. A piece of ground pumped up from the harbor bottom was dressed as a Pacific island, and the dressing suited it.
Shelter Island also took on the city's memory. The Tunaman's Memorial stands there, honoring the men of the tuna fleet that worked out of San Diego for much of the twentieth century. Nearby hangs the Friendship Bell, a gift from the city of Yokohama, given in 1958. Both stand on land that did not exist when the first tuna boats left this bay.
The second island came from the Navy. The carriers based across the bay at North Island needed a deeper channel, and in 1961 the dredging began. The spoil was pumped onto the flats in front of the airport, and over the next two years a long, narrow strip of land took shape there, joined to the shore at one end. It was dedicated in 1963.
Harbor Island began bare, as Shelter Island had. Hotels and marinas came later, laid out along its length, with the bay on one side and a protected basin on the other. One of those marinas belongs to the Sheraton San Diego Hotel & Marina, at 1380 Harbor Island Drive. From the hotel lawns a visitor looks across the bay toward Point Loma and North Island, standing on sand that once lay in the path of the carriers.
Neither project began as a plan to make real estate. Both began as a disposal problem. Each time the harbor was deepened, the spoil was put to work, and the city ended up with two new waterfronts it could lease to marinas and hotels. A deeper channel brought the carriers in. The sand from that channel became the place where people now keep their boats.
This is easy to forget from land. On Shelter Island, the drive along the water feels as settled as any old shoreline street, and on Harbor Island the hotels look as though they have always stood there. Only the shapes give it away. Both islands are long and thin and suspiciously tidy, as if someone had drawn them on a chart and then filled them in, which is roughly what happened.
The shapes are clearest from the water. JADA, the 65-foot wooden yawl launched at Stockton in 1938, keeps her home berth at the Sheraton marina on Harbor Island, so every sail she makes starts on dredged land. Heading out toward the harbor mouth, a sailor passes the long front of Harbor Island, then the downtown skyline falls behind, and Shelter Island comes up on the starboard hand with its marinas and its Polynesian rooflines, the Point Loma hills rising behind it. Both islands sit low and level in the water, the way spoil settles. The story of how the bay was dug and filled is one of the threads of the San Diego Bay history sail, told from the water both islands came out of.
Sources: Port of San Diego; San Diego History Center; Wikipedia articles Shelter Island (San Diego) and Harbor Island (San Diego); Wikipedia article San Diego Bay.
Hear this story where it happened. JADA sails past this very spot. Join the San Diego Bay History Sail →