The Bay Log · Stories of San Diego Bay

The Bennington Explosion of 1905

On July 21, 1905, the gunboat USS Bennington lay at anchor in San Diego Bay while her crew made ready to get underway. Then one of her boilers exploded. When the count was finished, about 66 men were dead. The sources give figures from 62 to 66. Dozens more were injured. Up to that day, no peacetime naval disaster in San Diego had killed so many people.

The number is the plain fact of it. The rest of this story is about what came after: who went in to get the injured out, where the dead were buried, and the stone that still marks them.

A Navy that had not yet moved in

The San Diego of 1905 had not yet become a Navy town. The Great White Fleet would not anchor off Coronado for another three years. Glenn Curtiss would not bring flying machines to North Island until 1911. The great shore establishments that now line the bay were decades away. A gunboat at anchor in the harbor was a visitor, one ship in a port that was still mostly a commercial town on a quiet bay.

That is part of why the disaster struck the city so hard. Nothing in San Diego was built to handle a mass casualty event at sea. There was no naval hospital on the shore and no large base to absorb the shock. A town that was mostly merchants, fishermen and the families who served them took in a catastrophe on the scale of a battle.

What a boiler holds

A warship of that era ran on coal and steam. In her boilers, water was held under pressure and heated past the point where it would boil in open air. As long as the boiler holds, that water stays liquid and its energy goes where the engineers send it: into the pipes, the engines and the shafts that turn the propellers.

When a boiler fails, the pressure drops at once, and the superheated water flashes into steam in an instant. Steam at that temperature scalds anyone it reaches. The firerooms and engine spaces of a gunboat were cramped and low and reached by ladders. The men working there had little room to get clear. On a ship preparing to get underway, steam was being raised and the engineering spaces were fully manned.

The details of what failed aboard the Bennington and why were the business of the Navy's inquiry. The result is the part on record: a ship at anchor in calm harbor water, and casualties on the scale of a battle.

Eleven Medals of Honor

Eleven men received the Medal of Honor for their rescue efforts that day. In that era the Navy awarded its highest decoration for heroism in peacetime as well as in combat, and the Bennington drew more of those awards than almost any single event of the period.

The citations honor rescue. On a ship where a boiler has just burst, rescue means going toward the steam, down into spaces where scalded men cannot climb out by themselves, and carrying them up. Eleven men did that work well enough that the Navy put their names on its roll beside men decorated in war.

The ridge above the harbor

The dead were buried at the post cemetery at Fort Rosecrans, on the spine of Point Loma above the harbor entrance. It was a small Army burial ground for a coastal fort. The Bennington dead filled it with more graves at once than it had ever received. The post cemetery later became Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery, and the Bennington graves remain there among the long white rows.

In 1908 a granite obelisk was dedicated on that ground in their memory. The Bennington Monument still stands in the national cemetery. It is plain, tall and grey against the ranks of white headstones that grew up around it over the following century. Visitors walking the cemetery's paths come upon it as the oldest large memorial on the ridge, raised to men who died in no war at all.

The monument says something about how the Navy and the city chose to remember. The men of the Bennington were not killed by an enemy. They died at their work, in a harbor, on a summer day, and those who survived them decided that this deserved granite and a permanent place on the point.

From the water

A sailor coming in past the Zuniga jetty today has Point Loma close on the port hand, and the rows of the national cemetery run along the ridge above Ballast Point and the submarine base. The Bennington Monument stands among them. Most boats pass under that ridge without anyone aboard knowing who is up there. The water the gunboat anchored in in 1905 is the same water the carriers now cross on their way to North Island. If you want to see the point and its history from the deck of a 1938 wooden yawl, the San Diego Bay history sail passes beneath the ridge where the Bennington's crew was laid to rest.

Sources: Naval History and Heritage Command, Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships entry for Bennington; U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, National Cemetery Administration, Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery; Congressional Medal of Honor Society records; Wikipedia articles "USS Bennington (PG-4)", "Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery" and "Bennington Monument".

Hear this story where it happened. JADA sails past this very spot. Join the San Diego Bay History Sail →

← All Bay Log stories